Feminism, Jewish Women, and History
by Suzanne Reisman

Earlier this week, as I prepared to celebrate Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, which began last night at sundown, I decided that honoring the contributions of Jewish women to feminism would make for a fitting essay. Immediately obvious to me was the enormous influence Jewish women had on the "Second Wave" of feminism.

Many people with a only passing knowledge of feminism practically equate it with Gloria Steinem and Betty Friedan. Of course, these women are probably the most famous Second Wave feminists, and both happened to be Jewish. The Second Wave is full of other Jewish women, such as Susan Sontag, Alix Kates Shulman, Susan Brownmiller, Shulamith Firestone, Judy Chicago, etc., etc. Interestingly, many of these women first became turned onto activism as part of the Civil Rights Movement.

While I had no problem finding information about Jewish Second Wave or even Third Wave feminists (although finding blog posts about them not written by right-wing ranters, raving anti-Semites, or lurid white supremacists was disappointingly difficult – if you have something lucid to say about these women, please blog about it and post your links in the comments!!!), I realized that as the First Wave of feminism is traditionally defined, it leaves out pretty much any women leaders who were not white, upper middle class, and Christian. The suffrage movement is of course critical to the rights that women have today, and I would never denigrate the amazing work done by the early feminist pioneers and the painful punishment often meted out to them. (If you haven't seen the HBO movie Iron Jawed Angels, put it on your Netflix list ASAP.) But, just as the mainstream, middle-class, white, heterosexual-led Second Wave feminist movement is rightly criticized for its exclusiveness, my exploration of Jewish feminist leaders led me to re-think how I look at the First Wave of feminism.

If we think about feminism as promoting human rights, it is fair to say that a number of prominent Jewish (as well as African-American) women were paving the way for future generations in the late 1800s and early 1900s when they agitated for abolition and worker's rights. Danya Ruttenberg, a Third Wave Jewish feminist activist writer and rabbinical student who blogs at Jerusalem Syndrome, pointed me to a number of early Jewish feminists who existed outside of the conventional First Wave movement. How I ever could have forgotten Emma Goldman, a personal hero of mine while I sought alternative role models when I was in high school? Kim from Emergiblog honored Lillian Wald, nurse, feminist, founding member of the NAACP. Thanks to Danya, I learned about Hannah Greenebaum Solomon, child welfare advocate and founder of the progressive National Council of Jewish Women. Suddenly, I remembered Rose Schneiderman, a labor organizer and advocate of worker education for both men and women who was the subject of my college thesis. These women may have worked outside of the traditional feminist framework of the era, but the work they did benefited people of all stripes to this day.

It takes many people from all walks of life to create and enrich a vibrant feminist movement. On this first day of the Jewish year 5768, I am proud to be counted as one of a long line of Jewish women who want to make the world a better place for everyone.

To learn more about Jewish feminists, check out the wonderful online exhibit Jewish Women and the Feminist Revolution from the Jewish Women's Archive (JWA). The site features dozens of Jewish feminist activists from the late 1800s to today, many of whom also sought/seek to work in partnership with others to address biases against low-income women, women of color, and/or non-heterosexual women. The JWA also has a thoughtful group blog, Jewesses with Attitude.

----

Suzanne proudly self-identifies as "Jewish white trash" much to the horror of her parents and blogs at Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS) & Other Rants

Comments

 

Jewish woman on "Mad Men"

Thanks, Suzanne, for sharing about all these great women.

Have you seen Mad Men at all? It's on AMC. There's a very interesting Jewish woman character who's running her father's department store. She has some great scenes in the first few episodes, so maybe catch it when it comes out on DVD.

Liz Rizzo

I blog at Everyday Goddess and On The Lot.

 

Never heard the expression "Jewish White
Trash" before

I have no idea what it means..but a very happy, healthy and sweet New Year to you Suzanne ! If "Jewish White Trash" is how you want to self-identify then I assume the term only means good stuff.
Thanks for linking to the exhibit -- it is truly wonderful and it did make me feel so proud of the role that Jewish women have played and are playing in the feminist movement
So many people associate Jewish women with the stereotyped "Jewish American Princess" -- so its nice to focus on the powerful, strong and dedicated women who are working to leave the world a better place.

elana
Blogher Contributing Editor,Business&CareersFunnyBusiness

 

Definition of "Jewish White Trash"

I always joke that I am "Jewish white trash" because so many people think of Jews as being rich and living carefree lifestyles in big houses in the suburbs. My parents sort of halfway made it - my dad's a CPA (how Jewish!) and my mom a teacher's aide and their house is in a nice suburb, but that's about it. It's on the "wrong side of the highway" and not maintained at the highest standards, filled with a lot of mis-matched furniture and kitschy crap. For example, a photo of us with Dennis Franz (from "Hill Street Blues" and "NYPD Blue"), who we ran into when my family took a vacation when I was going into 6th grade, is stuck to the living room with masking tape and has been there so long, when my mom took it down recently, we noticed that the wall behind the picture was darker than the faded wall around it. You know, it's almost more like people expect from trailer park decor, but not quite. I find it very endearing.

Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants

 

Not so fond of the "Jewish White Trash" name,
but "get it"

I know what you mean about being judged solely on Jewish stereotypical traits. The neighborhood in which I grew up had a Jewish side (aligned neatly to the stereotype) and a Christian side (mainly blue collar workers). A "them vs. us" mentality existed on both sides.

I lived in the Christian side. My mother took me to Hebrew lessons and Sunday school, but she got ill early in my childhood and couldn't continue to raise me as a Jew. My father was not the child-rearing type.

Shortly after we moved into the neighborhood, our home was burglarized. This occurred after I had invited a new "friend" to my house. She saw my mother's spinet piano in the living room and commented on how lucky we were to have nice things. The reality was that our home was fairly Spartan-like. The piano was the exception and my mother's passion.

Several weeks later, a swastika was painted on our front door (perhaps because nothing of interest resulted from the burglary).

We lived in that neighborhood for many years and made many friends. In the big picture, those early experiences were insignificant. Small minds think small thoughts.

I felt that the kids on the Jewish side of the tracks thought of me as "Jewish White Trash." “Trash” people of any background is a derogatory term in connotation. I know that you mean the term in jest -- I share my experiences only to explain why, for me, the term is uncomfortable.

- Maurene

P.S. I'd like to add my mother Freda Caplan to the list of feminist Jewish women.

E-Communications & Community
Never let the urgent crowd out the important.

 

I'd add the following:

When I think of Jewsih women who were in the lead of 1st Wave Feminism I also would add Andrea Dworkin for her anti-porn work and Letty Cottin Pogrebin for co-founding Ms Magazine and writing about feminism and motherhood and feminism and the business world.

In the early days of feminist activism getting a mimeographed pamphlet written by these and some of the women you mentioned was like getting word from a distant and exciting shore.

~~ Contributing Editor, and aging 1st wave feminist, Mata H. also blogs along at Time's Fool

 

Hi All

Hi!

I heartily support the fact that Jewish women have probably had more equality than Christian women. On the other hand, it is with some trepidation that I will add the following note. My grandfather was head of the Dutch underground. He spent a 700-year old fortune helping Jews get out of Europe in the Netherlands.

He was shot by the Nazis in a concentration camp by a firing squad.

We've been asked to make films about his life.

My mother has refused.

The reason is the following which I do not think anyone within the family has ever discussed in public before.

After the war, many people came to thank my grandmother for giving not only her husband but her first born son to the efforts.

Many Christians, the Americans, there are monuments to him and roads named after him.

Not one Jewish person ever wrote a thank you note in the 50+ years my grandmother lived in the same place where so many Jews had been helped on her farm.

I know it was a horrible war, and I know there was a great deal to forgive and forget, but one thank you would have been nice.

Love,

Alixandra
www.angelmystics.com
http://www.blogtalkradio.com/angelmystics
http://freeclairvoyantandpsychicreadings.mypodcast.com/index.html

 

A thank you...

Your comment has veered severely away from the topic of Suzanne's post, which was about Jewish women and their contributions to feminism...

You might be better served by writing a blog post about this topic instead - it's a much better way to open a new discussion.

~Denise
Fast Times @ Homeschool High & Flamingo House Happenings