(Disclaimer - I write in the first person. Badly. And somewhat infrequently. So anything I say here is basically a general departure from the quality of journalistic intelligence and inteigrity that you otherwise read here at Blogher. Which is why a lot of times I feel like a total tool in this communitiy of brilliant gals. Anyway - feel free to read on if you like.)
My memories are riddled with awkward and odd snapshots of first generation Korean women who would sit in the last row of my church while growing up. They sat alone, in the back row of our church. These were my mother's best friends. Auntie Dina and Auntie Monica were quiet and stoic martyrs. They wore lace over their heads in church, were devoted volunteers, and exceptionally lovely and giving human beings. Their manners and demeaner were impeccable - as if they wanted to avoid any reason to stand out or cause scrutiny.
They were un-escorted by their respective husbands, who as white American men, while not unwelcome explicitly in our community, were seen and treated with a curious and none-to-subtle disdain for being outsiders. This circumstance of having the Korean half of a biracial couple go as second class and silent citizens within this otherwise tightknit and homogenous ethnic community was treated as normal and justifiable growing up in Michigan in the 80s.
So how now, do I feel as I'm encrouching on my impending nuptuals to a white American?
Myself, I've always been exceptionally proud to be a Korean American woman. Having been involved an a wide array of Asian specific community organizations - from my Asian interest sorority, to being president of the Korean Students Association in college, and being now involved with the Asian American Theater Company -- not to mention having had my own column for 6 years at a nationally distributed Korean American magazine -- has put me squarely in the bracket of "Non-white washed" and yet non "Fobby'. (White-washed being the term to describe Asian Americans who eschew any part of their ethnic identity and FOB describing fresh of the boat or v. recent immigrants).
Earlier in the month I ran into an old girlfriend of mine whom I'd not seen in half a decade. I briefly introduced her to my fiancee outside the restaurant that we'd bumped into her at.
Her: "Wow. I never thought you'd wind up with a white guy."
Me; "Yeah, go figure. I used to write essays or blogged on why white guys needed to exfoliate more, were kinda more shaggy than I liked, smelled different, and that I wasn't generally, of my own volition, attracted to them."
Her: "So what happened?"
Me: "I fell in love with him. Nothing else really mattered."
And in that respect, it's absolutely true. But it took me an extraordinary long journey to come to this point.
Boyfriend 1: Korean Christian Harvard Premed Acapella singer - aka my parent's wet dream.
Boyfriend 2: Chinese American fellow that had the best hair ever and would trace the alphabet with his mouth on my knee.
Boy I kissed: A cute white guy who I referred to as my farewell college fling. I told none of my Asian American sorority girlfriends about him.
Boyfriend 3: Chinese American fellow that had the worst wardrobe ever.
Boyfriend 4: Adopted Asian American of White parents with more issues than you could shake a stick at - even if you were having epileptic seizures and had a venti of starbucks
Boys I kissed - oh - it's a benetton advertisment at the end of the day. Actually, maybe it's more like that "I'd like to teach the world to sing" Coca Cola ad from the late 80s. I admit too much.
Bi-racial couples are not as uncommon in this day and age as they used to be while I was growing up -- quietly observing and inadvertantly indoctrining myself for bias against that possibility.
"Oh him -- total Asian fetish. Gross"
"Her? She's only into white guys. Kind of a sell out."
"He only dates FOBs with funky teeth and don't know any better. All the American (and by American we mean Asian American, White American, Latina America, etc.) chicks realize he's a tool - he's lucky for the language barrier."
In fact, it's a running joke amongst my friends that to be a true bay area hipster god you have to move to san francisco, work in tech, and if you're a white guy - have an Asian girlfriend. Bi-racial couples are pervasive in San Francisco. But then again, so are all kinds of couples - but those are the ones that have seemed to stuck out a bit more to me lately.
The number of bi-racial couples that I consider amongst my circle of friends is a healthy set. And they're all absolutely normal.
And by normal, I mean that they don't seem to feel a need to justify their romance. They seem un-selfconscious about their ethnic identity, their national identity (ie - korean = ethnic and american = nationality and we eat burgers with kimchi and play warcraft and hate the president and watch volleyball matches and know way more than we ought to about golf because we hear about it all the time from our parents) and their romantic engagements - but there's no sense of feeling out of place or awkward or exclusive for sake of any community now.
How far have we *really* come in 20 or so years?
Were I not so absolutely confident about my identity within the Asian American community, I might still feel slightly rattled by the looks I get when I'm out with Asian American set of social groups. My honey? He feels absolutely unselfconscious and unawkward - oblivious to any odd psychic blips that I have pinging my radar. And when I'm out at social engagements that are more predominantly white, (as if there is such a thing in the bay area) I don't feel awkward or weird either. Maybe it's just in my head when I feel as if I have to justify something to someone out there somewhere who might be judging me somehow in that somewhat somewhereland.
Or maybe we've finally started getting it right.
That maybe if people treat you oddly at social circumstances, or are in any way (subtle or not) exclusive or peculiar -- maybe it's just because they legitimately think you're kind of an asshole and it has nothing to do with ethnicity,nationality, or social identity. I'd much prefer that then the idea that we haven't gotten any where since Aunties Dina and Monica.
Comments
I think it depends on your
I think it depends on your culture. My HK Chinese Catholic family is pretty open to my white, Jewish boyfriend. In fact, most of the white guys I've gone out with have been Jewish (which surprised many of my girlfriends. One (Asian) friend commented on how she was surprised that so many of the guys I've dated are Jews...she totally expected me to go out with either HK Chinese guys or WASPs, being so "Charlotte York" and all...but hey, Charlotte married a Jew, right?)...in fact, many Chinese women I know who married white guys, married Jewish men.
In terms of being in public with him, I haven't really noticed anything, except maybe at a certain Chinese/pan-Asian restaurant, but service is bad on weekends there anyway, so it's hard to prove anything. I live in Toronto, where interracial/interethnic dating is basically a part of everyday life.
my blogs:
Writing Blog (for updates on my writing and media plugs about my book)
Shorty Stories (a blog for petite activism)
More first person please
Min Jung,
This was fabulous! May I encourage you to keep writing in this style so you feel comfortable giving us more?
BlogHer CE
Kleenex® Let It Out Blog
Beyond Help
Min Jung, I really loved
Min Jung, I really loved reading your account. Your honesty and knack for telling the story is wonderful. It was great to get a sense of your experiences.
Bi-racial
I grew up half in Africa half in France and it is just great to participate in both culture.
It can be strange if you want to identify to only one, but if you embrace both the same way you embrace your parents, it is such a blessing.
Regards.
FD @ Condo-hotel Miami - Condo Hotel Miami Beach
Your account was very
Your account was very interesting; I had no idea really... Maybe it's because as a 'generic white woman' I've never
beenfelt part of 'a culture' and so never felt those feelings of myself or my mate being on the outside. I've dated outside my race, but never had those sorts of feelings. I thank you for sharing them.Also, I thought this might add to the discussion ~ a sort of the other side of the fence discovery from one of our guest writers.
Founder, Editor, of Sex-Kitten.Net
Thanks!
Hey ladies,
Thanks for the thoughtful feedback and support and good reading links. It's good to know that as a society we're moving more towards a culture of real kinship and relationships without the stigma that used to come from bi-racial dating.
In the end love rules!
http://www.minjungkim.com
Nice writing, Min Jung
I've been married to my Indian husband for 25 years now and we still get appraising looks, mostly from old ladies of both cultures, at the mall.
The culture clash I experienced became my writing's subject.
I may not have found a second family in the in-laws, but I can't say they never gave me anything!
http://shivasarms.blogspot.com
bi-racial feels normal
My husband is Korean American (I'm your average white Anglo), and when we lived in the Bay Area it felt totally normal for us to be a couple. So many of our friends are also bi-racial couples that it almost feels like all of them are (though if I think about it, that's not the case). Now that we live in Philadelphia we find that we're more of a rarity, to the extent that other bi-racial couples notice us, and we notice them. Many nods and smiles have been exchanged over the past four years here.
Even in my husband's family it doesn't seem so odd or unwelcoming as it did in the early days of our relationship. I don't think it was my mother-in-law's wish that her sons would both marry white women, but I think now she'd say that worked out OK. Grandchildren, even if mixed race, have a way of bridging gaps. :-)
Lori
www.avocado8.com
OMG LORI~!
We met *years and years and years* ago at a ladies blogger bruncheon in SF.
your name sounded familiar and i'm so glad to reconnect!
cheers on the happy life and reconnections!
http://www.minjungkim.com