Last year when I reported on the new Nair Pretty hair-removal product for pre-teens and the outcry it sparked, I had to admit that -- although it's a slippery slope -- it's not exactly unusual for a tween girl to be wondering about when to start shaving her legs. Nair was merely capitalizing on something already common.
And as I read various commentary from both the Nair marketing camp and other parents, I remember thinking that surely, the mainstream sexualization and objectification of our daughters had reached a new high.
It turns out that I'm something of an optimist when it comes to America's propensity to push girls into premature adulthood.
My friends, I am now yearning for the halcyon days when I thought that encouraging a tween to use a depilatory on her legs was scandalous, because today I am here to tell you that Philadelphia Magazine is reporting that girls as young as 8 are being taken to spas for everything from massages to bikini waxing.
Take a minute to digest that. 8-year-olds. Getting bikini waxes.
Moe at Jezebel expressed incredulity in the post titled How Many 8-Year-Olds Have To Get Bikini Waxes Before We All Agree The Terrorists Have Won, and quotes the original article just enough to point the finger of blame:
Today's girls aren't looking at posters; they're looking in the mirror. They have a new obsession — a self-obsession — and it's being aided and abetted by their mothers.
Their mothers who need to find something better to do.
At So Unpretty mo cheeks responds to the Philly article with condemnation of the female obsession with beauty:
girl world needs a break. like a serious time-out. all the make up, straightening irons, hot wax, etc. needs to be locked up for 3 months until everyone comes down from their botox highs.
i'm disappointed in womanity.
I am by no means excusing the mothers here, because indeed, I do cringe over what must be a deeply distorted body image and value system that would cause a woman to think this is an appropriate activity for a child. But I found myself nodding even more vigorously as I read BellaSugar's commentary, which points out that there's plenty of blame to go around:
It's easy to just blame these girls' mothers (and, ahem, where are their fathers?!). But I find it just as troubling that spa owners allow these unnecessary (and sometimes painful) procedures to be performed on children. Since the mothers are willing to drop big bucks on a regular basis to keep their daughters perfectly preened, salon owners risk losing the lucrative business should they refuse to perform a service. And from the sound of it, most of them would rather keep their traps shut than jeopardize their profits.
While the business angle bothers me, as well (though the triumph of the almighty dollar -- even in this scenario -- comes as a surprise to no one), I think the wondering where the fathers are is a really valid and depressingly novel point. The assumption is that this is a practice encouraged and abetted by mothers. Don't these girls have fathers, too? Isn't it both parents' job to shepherd our children through childhood at an appropriate pace?
In a comment thread about the article on the LiveJournal site f*ck_shaving (asterisk mine), commenter __nopanuru laments:
It's sad that all these moms can't think of anything else to do to bond with their daughters but go to the spa. What about taking a walk every evening to talk about their day, or cook together, or take up art classes or fucking something else.
[...]
Also, do any other these daughters have fathers? Do any of these women have husbands?
Don't they have some influence in their lives telling them that they're beautiful no matter what?
"Beautiful no matter what." Now there's a concept. I don't know if the women involved feel the need to go to such grooming extremes (themselves, which they then pass along to their ever-younger daughters) because the men in their lives demand it -- overtly or tacitly -- or because they've somehow internalized the "be young, hairless, and perfect" standard which American culture and Photoshop demand.
What I do know is that I am very, very afraid for our daughters' future when stuff like this is becoming the norm.
BlogHer Contributing Editor Mir also blogs at Woulda Coulda Shoulda and Want Not.
Comments
It's My Body and I'll Shave If I Want To!
Rewind 30 years...... I am sitting in on the waterbed in the bedroom of my best friend's parents. We have pulled all the Playboys out from their secret hiding place (which, if I remember correctly was out in the open on the bedside table) and 3 8 & 9 year old girls are looking at pictures of naked women. This is the 70's."Sexy" women in Playboy in the 1970's had curves, natural breasts and - GASP - pubic hair. Looking at "retro" playboys now, I am comforted by the image of real bodies, natural, human, that look a good deal like mine.
HOWEVER, even at that age, I looked at the mangled bush between their legs and hated it. I didn't like it. Even though it was being presented to me as sexy and desirable. Even though my mother, an ardent (and hairy and kind) feminist paraded her naked body comfortably thorugh the house in all it's natural glory. I did not like the hair. Was it a tactile response? Was it deeply imprinted from some early childhood experience? Was it imprinted deeply on my DNA the same way that some people think cliantro tastes like soap or brussel sprouts are impossibly bitter? I don't know. The point is, at that young age I had been shown nothing but natural bodies, and while I liked them, even in the very beginning of discovering my own nascent sexuality, I hated hair.
Period. NO LIKEY!
Now, I have never demonized anyone for liking it. For wanting it. For craving it. I just quietly set about removing all of mine because I am happier that way. And I have listened to the slings and arrows and judgements of others in way that is no less shallow and demeaning than those that suggest having hair is gross. Dogmatic judgement from either side is the SAME, no matter how vastly superior your own side is.
It is GREAT and IMPORTANT to teach our daughters that they are beautiful, sexy, powerful, strong and WORTHY exactly as they are. BUT it is just as important to teach them that they have the right to define beauty and sexy for themselves.
When we say, "if you choose to alter your body you are degrading yourself, me and women in general," we are putting a pressure on them - to validte ourselves - that they do not need, cannot handle and do not deserve.
What we need to be teaching our children - male and femal - is that they have the right to be true to themselves, define their own lives and have their deepest beliefs and desires met with purity and passion. This issue of grooming is a small doorway into larger issues of being able to deviate from the media depicted norm and manifest an external world that jibes with your own internal world. Are you gay even though no one around you approves of it? Do you want to be a housewife? President? Media inhernetly presents 2 dimensional archetyps - our job as parents is to teach our children that there are more than 2 dimensions.
My daughter is rapidly approaching puberty. She knows that I have removed all of my hair because I walk around naked all the time. We have talked about it. She asked why, I told her that it was because it was my body and I get to choose what to do with it. She asks if she'll want to do the same thing, and I tell her that there is no way to know yet. But that when she is an adult and knows herself and her body, she can make these decisions for herself.
Is it working? I don't know. But I do know that she will say to me, "mom, i don't know if I'll marry a man or a woman." And I smile. She is keenly aware that "growing up" is a process of discovery....
These companies that are marketing bikini waxes to 8 year-olds are disgusting. Totally. Sites like Miss Bimbo make me want to hurl and move to Peru. Parents that dress their kids in designer clothes make me want to run naked (and hairless) through the streets screaming, "What The F*CK is Wrong WIth You People?"
But we have to realize that by being as dogmatic and vitriolic in our opposition to these things, we are still laying an equally narrow and shallow example for our children and they will believe that in order to please us, they must walk that same path and feel that same way. We are inherently making deviants out of them, even if all they are doing is deviating from us by expressing an inner desire that is as foreign and real to them as my early revulsion with hair was for me.
I went on too long, I know. But we mut be carfeul here. I felt guilty and bad and dirty for years. I believed that i was letting down women in general.... Even as I started a business as a woman. Won major awards. Raised a daughter. Published articles....
You cannot define a beautiful and strong woman by either the presence or absence of pubic hair. It's the same message on either side - I'm defining you by your crotch.
We're past that, ladies. Or should be.
___________
Alyssa Royse
JUST CAUSE
Start Her Up: A blog for Women Entrepreneurs
I agree, no dogma
Alyssa, I think i understand the point you're making and I think
it's a valid and important one. Of course there is nothing wrong with
being hairless if that's what a woman (or anyone, for that matter)
wants as a matter of self-choice.
I maintain that there is something VERY wrong with obtaining an
expensive and painful procedure for a girl probably too young to need
or want it. There is something very wrong with TELLING a young girl
"this is what we do" when you're discussing ANY extreme grooming ritual
suitable for an adult and not a child.
And that's where the crux of this lies, for me: These are children. These are extreme choices, ones for adults to make. Are any of these choices "bad" or "wrong" for everyone? Of course not. But I don't care if you "knew" at 8 that you never wanted any body hair -- if your mother took you to have your genitals waxed at such a tender young age, I would cry foul. No, actually -- I take that back.
I would cry child abuse.
It's not about the hair. It's about adult decisions affecting little girls, ones that are irrevocably tied up in an artificial yardstick of what constitutes beauty.
I'm sure there were some Chinese little girls who "knew" they didn't want big feet, but that doesn't make foot binding any less abusive.
This cannot be talked about JUST as a matter of hair or even beauty preferences. No one is saying your preference is wrong or bad. All I'm saying is that children should get to be children.
--
Mir Kamin
(BlogHer Mommy & Family contributing editor)
Personal: Woulda Coulda Shoulda
Having it all with less: Want Not
COULD NOT AGREE MORE STRONGLY!
Seriously, telling children they need to wax is insane. i'm not even sure i'd let her if she asked, but i guess i'll cross that bridge when i come to it.
But i do think that we need to be very careful in how we present choices to our kids. At every turn. I know that I have one dialog in my head while something bizarrely rational and compassioante comes out of my mouth.
Talking about things like, for example, the Spears girls (who are the all time best discussion starter ever for parents of girls, thank you, god or someone, for them!) Whenever they come up in conversation I hear myself talking about choices and decisions and learning.... When what's going through my head are all sorts of things that are judgemental and cruel, however accurate. :)
As for waxing and spa days. Manicures etc... are one thing. Kids have been playing "house" and "dress up" forever. It's modeling and they'll do it. But the things like waxing and dieting - that's adult behavior and needs to be explained as such. But explained as a personal choice, not one that has all sorts of societal baggage on it - and not good / bad / right / wrong. Just choice.
I totally agree with you. Really. I just happen to hate body hair.
___________
Alyssa Royse
JUST CAUSE
Start Her Up: A blog for Women Entrepreneurs
You can guess my opinion on kids and bikini
waxing...
Hint: Not into it.
Suzanne Reisman, Contributing Editor - Feminism & Gender
Campaign for Unshaved Snatch (CUSS)& Other Rants
really, Suzanne?
I am shocked. SHOCKED, I tell you. ;)
--
Mir Kamin
(BlogHer Mommy & Family contributing editor)
Personal: Woulda Coulda Shoulda
Having it all with less: Want Not
I am locking my daughter up now.
I take a lot of heat for letting my daughter go whole-hog on the princess thing, but it's sad when the rest of the world makes a totally outdated view of womanhood look safer than the present one in some ways.
Surrender, Dorothy - When I was your age, we just let them ride in the back window.